After deliberation, here are the results of the first Wikidot Theme Contest. Our decisions were based on the quality, originality and utility of the themes.
The runners up are, in no particular order: Woodcut by Chris Bond, Monobook by Fereal, Dark Blue by jiminy35, and Northern Lights by RobElliott. Congratulations to these prize winners, who will get their Pro account upgrades. Those who already have Pro status can choose to gift their prize to another deserving contributor, or get upgraded to Pro+.
The winner of the themes contest is Articles 'n More, by Timothy Foster. Nicely done, Timothy! Your account will be upgraded to Pro+, and we'll get in touch about your iPod.
We did not issue the fifth runner-up prize because the other contest themes all had aspects that we felt disqualified them. However, we'll be running a new theme contest in a few months, and all themes that have not (yet) won a prize can be resubmitted.